SB Nation - Login for mobile commenting

Burnt Orange Nation

Saturday Scrimmage Notes

Goooood morning, Horns fans. Some of you may have been up bright and early like I was this morning, and if you got yourself together in time, made it to DKR for the a.m. scrimmage. As promised, notes from this morning's action.

Colt McCoy is your starter. Absolutely no doubt about it. McCoy started with the first team offense, moved the ball well, looked very, very comfortable and poised with his reads, and delivered the ball exactly where he should have. Just judging from his presence, decision-making, and performance, you'd not guess he's a freshman.

What was absolutely clear from today was that McCoy has built a rapport with the first team and feels, looks, and acts like the job is his. A lot can happen between now and game day, so caveat emptor... but if I were a betting man, and I am, I'm betting the house on McCoy.

That brings us to Jevan, who I was eager to see today. Let's just say that he's most assuredly had better days. He was picked off once, should have been picked off another time, and, most importantly, is taking too long to decide what to do with the ball.

Fans who watched the Titans' preseason opener saw Vince Young play reasonably well, but it was clear he was thinking a lot out there. That's a characteristic you see in someone that's still learning how to make his reads and digesting the offense.

Same with Snead. As receivers made their breaks, and the ball should have been released from his hand, he was still looking around, deciding where to go. On the three throws where he made a decision on time and threw the ball in, he looked good. He threaded the needle on one very nice throw to his left, and it's clear he has some real talent. But based on what I saw today, he's not ready, and isn't going to be our starter.

What was -really- interesting is that...

...Sherrod Harris outplayed Snead by a lot today. So much so that I asked myself if Snead, and not Harris, should be the one redshirting.

Then, of course, I reminded myself that this is one practice, and I can't draw any conclusions off of one practice. Still, Horns fans shouldn't write off Harris. He looked very comfortable in the zone read, made a gorgeous throw on a deep ball that was dropped (exactly like VY's throw in the Titans' opener), and looked comfortable out there. He was picking on third team defenders mostly, but he's sort of the forgotten man among Longhorn fans. I won't forget him after today. He has real talent.

Most interesting thing I saw today: the number of plays run out of the two tight-end set. There were a lot of them. There are some distinct pros to such a set for this particular team:

  1. It puts both Jermichael Finley and Neale Tweedie on the field at the same time. This has numerous advantages, most notably that we can disguise whether we intend to use Finley as our receiver, or Tweedie as our man to run behind.
  2. It's a fine set up for a team that's lacking in a great fullback but wants to run the football a healthy number of times.
The first team defense was impenetrable. The second team offense, faced with the task of trying to move on this unit, could not. They could not run. They could not throw. Snead was ineffective against this unit (as well as the second team unit, which he saw action against later). As expected, the unit looks big, fast, and tough. Sounds simple, and it is. The first team defense is disgusting.

Staying with the defense: Frank Okam is an absolute monster. He's going to require two blockers on every play he's in, and if teams try to use one man against him, he'll disrupt the play in the backfield, as he did on one occasion this morning. Offensive coaches better gameplan for Okam; those that don't will be in big, big trouble.

Marcus Griffin got the start at safety alongside brother and returning starter Michael Griffin. He's more than adequate, but I was particularly impressed with Erick Jackson today, and won't be surprised if he winds up our starter at safety. Both will play; both looked good.

Jamaal Charles was unbelievable today, as one might expect, but so was Selvin. Young looked quick, strong, and made several impressive runs, including one he made a perfect cut inside on for a touchdown.

For his part, Charles looked every bit the best tailback in the country, as I think he might be. High praise for a true sophomore, but if he stays healthy, look out. He's so incredibly balanced, he maintains a perfect body position in traffic, bounces off would-be tacklers while always keeping his legs moving, and of course has that unreal speed. He'll share duties with Selvin, which is fine by me, but if he were the sole featured tailback, I've no doubt he'd run for 2,000 yards and wind up in New York as a Heisman finalist.

Henry Melton got significant action today, and didn't look much better than last year. He looked a little more spry, but he's still running too upright, and he runs into the pile too frequently. It was just one scrimmage, but the improvement I've been hearing about wasn't evident today.

Limas Sweed is ready. For one thing, he's grown into his frame, filled out, looks right, looks comfortable, runs good routes, isn't afraid to use his body... just nothing bad to say about Limas at this point. He looked like a leader out there, and like a man who knows he can succeed. That's a lot of development from his freshman year, when he was timid and unsure of himself, and his sophomore year, when he was still growing into his role as a go-to receiver.

McCoy hit Sweed twice, once on a perfect out (Sweed made a great catch, and bounced off a would-be tackler), and once on a deep ball to the outside (perfect throw, great route by Sweed). McCoy to Sweed looked like a great combo today.

Greg Davis haters prepare your eyes for some rolling - the bubble screen is back. I'm just sayin'...

Deon Beasley was fielding punts before the scrimmage, but only saw action at cornerback in the live ball. He didn't -quite- look ready to me. He's a terrific athlete, though, and will be an asset by mid-season. Chykie Brown saw some solid minutes with the second and third units as well. Both will play this season.

Greg Johnson did a great job as our kickoff man, punter, and place kicker. Hunter Lawrence shared the duties, but didn't perform nearly as well. His kickoffs were decent, but no match for Johnson's arching, hanging deep balls, and Lawrence had a field goal blocked on a ball that never got up. Hunter made his final attempt and looked much better. I'd hate to see Johnson have to do it all, but right now, he's the best man for the job. We'll see. This remains an area of concern.

Overall, I was eager to see these guys live, and I came away feeling good. The starters (I'm counting McCoy in here) looked great, and there are lots of guys already there, or well on there way, to provide excellent depth. The secondary is going to be deep, with plenty of rotation. The starting linebackers were excellent; the guys behind them looked solid, and will keep getting better. The defensive line was the best I've seen at Texas, as expected. On offense, the receivers are ready, the tailbacks are terrific, and the offensive line did a solid job. For those wondering, Blalock spent a lot of time at tackle today, with Dockery playing solidly at guard.

Oh, one more thing: at this time two weeks from now, Texas will be kicking off their season opener against North Texas. You ready?

Update [2006-8-19 11:28:56 by HornsFan]: Can't believe I forgot to mention this: the scoreboard is freaking ENORMOUS!! You have to see it to appreciate just how gigantic it is. Ohmygod.

--PB--

0 recs  |  25 comments

Comments

Alright Peter
My recap mirrors yours in almost every way.  But... I didn't see the same Jamaal Charles you saw!  I thought Selvin looked far better and far more aggressive.  At least from where I was sitting, it didn't look like JC was going full-speed on his touches, whereas Selvin was 110% on all of his.

Not that JC isn't going to be amazing, and the feature back all season, but I was way more impressed with Selvin this morning.

I'm glad you saw the same Henry Melton though.  After all the good news we'd been hearing from the Spring and Summer workouts, I was really expecting to see a whole new Hank.  I was extremely disappointed in what I saw this morning.

Disagree completely
JC is just patient. It's one of those attributes that you can't teach, but he waits for the holes.

Contrast his running, for example, to Melton, who I mentioned kept running into piles. When it looks like JC is creeping along, he's looking for that hole to develop; when it opens, he goes right through it. The balance and patience made him a tough tackle today, and he completely wowed me with that.

Selvin was quick and excellent and I was as impressed as you were, but he doesn't have -quite- the same instincts that JC does.

Just my perspective.

Or Ramonce
Ramonce Taylor, an absolutely amazing athlete, lacked those instincts that JC has. He was a straight downhill runner; if the hole wasn't wide open, he wasn't nearly as effective. What makes JC elite is the ability to wait and explode.
Agree on RT
In fact, if there wasn't a hole, he would start running THE WRONG DIRECTION to try to make something from nothing.

I was at the Southeast end of the stadium, so I was miles away from the line of scrimmage for most of JC's plays, so I'll take your word for his performance today.

Anyway, it's a nice problem to have - to absolutely stud RB's to choose from for the whole season.  More likely for them both to stay healthy if we're not counting on one of them to get 35 touches a game.

Just saw your notes
Just saw your notes from the scrimmage, patienthornsfan, and looks like we saw all the same things.

I can't say I feel uncomfortable about McCoy AT ALL after today. He's got real presence and reminds me a little bit of... Drew Brees. Same size, deceptively athletic, great presence and touch. I'm very happy this morning.

I agree - lots of progress from Spring Scrimmage
Colt definetly looks to be in charge.  I think he'll get the bulk of the time against North Texas, and will be the clear starter for tOSU, which puts my worries about rotating QB's to rest for now.

And what about Sherrod??  You know, as you say, it's one scrimmage, but I think your suggestion of shirting Jevan and keeping Harris as the backup this season doesn't seem so far-fetched.

Hey, maybe Jevan just had an off day, and he WAS facing the 2nd or 3rd best defensive unit in the country all day.  Whatever the reason, I'm glad it happened.  Makes McCoy the absolute lock as the starting QB.

Great notes
It pleases me to no end to know that Sherrod is turning it up and is actually in the mix.  I don't think it's likely that he will wind up the starter (given your notes on McCoy), but he would be an excellent back-up to throw defenses off their game.  He adds a different dimension to the game (much like VY did).  If he survives and stays at QB, we've got 4, and maybe 5 (with Chiles) QB's in two years that could fight for playing time.  

Anyone else about to rip the calendar apart waiting for Sept.?

This post
was probably the best post I've ever read.

A large part is because I'm actually, physically drooling for football, but also because while you jackasses woke up early Saturday morning to watch football, I woke up Saturday morning to go in to work.  I've never been so excited and jealous at the same time.

Bummer
Sorry you're at work, TROT. Glad the notes could provide a brief moment of escape. Two weeks 'til kickoff.
Bean, questions:
  1. Any take on Orapko. This is my sleeper for the season. I saw him in spring drills and he was absolutely tearing up the tackle that was trying to block him.
  2. Derek Lokey?
  3. Roy Miller?
  4. Sweed is the shit. You will most definitely be reminded of how much I love this guy when you come to my tailgate for N. Texas. Hint: Rooster Andrews doesn't know a damn thing about licensing for UT Jerseys.
  5. 2 tight end set? Kind of like the old ball control scrimmage Austin High used to run. Let me tell you, I don't like it that much. 2 tight ends allows the defense to focus more men in the box for "free". Unless Tweedie(sp) is the best blocker in the nation, it's not going to do much good to run the shotgun read out of a 2 tight end set. By running 2 tight ends, you are allowing safeties and or a corner to stack up in the middle with no real assignment. Unfortunately, many teams safeties are their best athletes, which is not what I want to see. I would rather have a split out WR, than 2 tight ends.
  6. Sorry about the long post. I am excited as shit.
NEWBS
In order
1) Orakpo is very solid, but more so as a pass rusher than as a run stuffer. On one running play to his side, he got absolutely creamed.

2, 3) Lokey and Miller are specimens. Funny specimens; freaking short, stocky, with tree trunks for legs. Both will be good at eating blockers, which is the main thing we need from them. Again, though, Okam is the star. He was the best player on the field.

  1. Can't wait for the Newbs tailgate! I've grown to love Sweed a lot, too. He really has come a long way; he was great in the Rose Bowl, too.
  2. I don't want to get too much into the formations at this point, and you raise some good points, but there are definitely worse things than having Tweedie and Finley out there together, ESPECIALLY because of how good a receiver J-Mike can be. He's going to be a mismatch nightmare for some linebackers.
props
This is exactly why I come here every day - excellent post.  Thanks.  Now comes the most excruciating two-week waiting period.
Thanks Jason
Happy to hear it from the guy who keeps me honest.

Much appreciated.

Awesome stuff PB
How did Shipley look?  

Also, any insight into the FB situation?

Ship, Fullbacks
Ship was running as a "second team" wide receiver, which meant he was facing the first team defense for the first half of the scrimmage. Unfortunately for him, Snead never got comfortable against that unit, and never threw it his way.

Shipley did catch one pass, but I believe Matt McCoy was passing at the time.

In any case, I hadn't seen much of him, so I watched him pretty closely. He's extremely quick off the line - quicker than any of the other receivers, his routes are terrific - never gives them away to the defender - and he has breakaway speed. I was impressed.

He's gonna play plenty, and if McCoy is any good (as he was today), Ship will have plenty of catches.

Today, Pittman, Sweed and Cosby were your first team wide receivers for the most part. There'll be plenty of action for all.

As for fullback, Chris Ogbonnaya got quite a few reps, but we really aren't running many plays with FBs these days. I didn't notice Marcus Myers much, but I wasn't looking closely for him. Personally, a switch to FB by Big Henry might be fun to watch. Just not much to report right now.

Just to add to this...
The crowd went crazy when Shipley caught his first pass.  It was evident that many of the other fans in the stands felt the same way we do.  I really hope this kid is as good as everything I have read.
The comments on
Melton seem to be universal that he's a project.

Apparently coach Rucker was all over him during the scrimmage preaching the basics. (give him time I guess)

I feel like my "inside" source with the training staff has let me down(college roomate is a PT). He made Snead sound like the next Elway and said the mood of the coaches was in his direction last spring. I guess things have changed.

I would hate to be Mack right now. This has now become a 3 QB derby, but not for the starting spot -- and even though Colt is the starter, what if he stinks against NT? Who does he put in? Who becomes the redshirt?
Its safe to assume that somebody is transferring after the season.

Could Harris be the next James Brown?

The last practice I attended was with Chance Mock starting -- and I walked away thinking he was a Heisman contender.

We aren't going to know until the lights come on and until they take that first monster hit that says, "welcome to D1 football".

QB Situation
"Its safe to assume that somebody is transferring after the season."

Nope.  Too soon to say that.  Who knows what's going to happen during the course of the season?  McCoy could self-destruct.  Snead could get hurt.  Harris could switch to WR or D.  (I'm knocking on wood as I type all of this!!!)  I know we have two studs coming in the 2007 class, but I wouldn't count on anyone throwing in the towel amongst the three contenders we have on the field this season just yet.

Video of the Scrimmage
I work a KEYE and we have about three minutes of the scrimmage on our website. (FYI, that's all UT allows.) We'll have interviews with players there soon. Longhorn Football section
Very Nice
PB, my compliments...that is the first thing I've read on Longhorn football this summer that didn't make me say, "well, no shit Shirlock."

My dad was also at their and he had the same things to say about Sherrod. Between McCoy, Snead, Harris, and the prospects of this Blantley kid coming, it's a good bet two of those four QB's won't be at Texas in two years. Too bad they had to come to UT all at the same time.

Side Note: If you don't already read the Dallas Morning News, go to the Web site and read the article about the AP Top 25 that just came out. The columnist explains why he voted for tOSU and #1 and why their defense could be even better even better this year. This entire summer, all we've heard is how tOSU's defense lost 9 starters, well this article talks about who is taking their places and why they won't miss a step. A word of caution: it'll make sick and maybe even rethink your prediction for Sept. 9.

Regardless, UT's defense is also one of the best and I still like our chances.

We're getting close now.

Thank ya sir
Glad your Dad got to attend, as well.

As for the Dallas Morning News article, I smell bullshit, but I'm gonna take your word and head over for a close read. Thanks for pointing out the article.

It's gonna be fun
Headed over to check out the recommended article - for those interested, here it is.

I'm not sure I fear the tOSU defense any more after reading it, but I do think ranking them #1 in the preseason is completely fair, and the article makes a fine case for it.

Longhorn fans should be especially attuned to just how much strong quarterback play can mean for your chances of winning 'em all.

54b, you are right, sir: we're getting close.

Thank God.

The DMN
article doesn't change my opinion. The guys that played last year made little to no contribution. The guy that subbed for Carpenter only registered one tackle in two games.

Their entire secondary is as green as Ireland.

Most important question
Has somebody instructed Colt McCoy to mime holster his pistols after every touchdown pass?  So essential.

Also, if the 'Horns are half as good as advertised/you saw yesterday morning, the rest of the nation could be in some trouble.

You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of Burnt Orange Nation to post a comment.